`


THERE IS NO GOD EXCEPT ALLAH
read:
MALAYSIA Tanah Tumpah Darahku

LOVE MALAYSIA!!!

 


 




Thursday, November 19, 2026

Drama Negeri Sembilan: Kemelut jadi lebih kalut

 Apa yang pada awalnya dilihat sebagai pertembungan antara Umno dan istana kini menjadi pergelutan antara orang Umno.

tajuddin rasdi

Dari kemelut tidak ada exco dan tak boleh buka persidangan Adun, membawa pula kepada kekalutan nama calon menteri besar baharu dikemuka kepada Yang Dipertuan Besar ketika menteri besar masih bertugas.

Kita semua tahu titah beginda kelmarin — selepas meeting dengan Ismail Lasim — adalah ‘you continue on as Menteri Besar’ atau mahfumnya lah. Jadi, apa halnya Umno kemuka another calon to the same royal person untuk diangkat menjadi menteri besar? Adakah ini akan berakhir dengan Negeri Sembilan ada dua menteri besar nanti?

Kalau kita dengar penjelasan pengulas politik popular, Iswardy Morni, akan ada suatu naratif tentang the story behind the drama yang semacam menyokong hujah-hujah beliau. Saya tak mahu ulang di sini, tuan-tuan boleh pergi ke saluran YouTube beliau.

Jadi, apa akan jadi di Negeri Sembilan?

Ismail dan presiden Umno mengatakan mahu menyelesaikan kemelut yang entah siapa mulakan ini supaya rakyat boleh dijaga tanpa banyak drama. Saya amat bersetuju atas niat yang nampak ikhlas kedua-dua tokoh politik Melayu ini. Sefaham saya, Ismail memulakan langkah untuk mengakhiri stalemate dengan menarik balik surat yang mahu menurunkan Tuanku Muhriz Tuanku Munawir dari takhta.

Ismail memohon untuk menghadap, dan diberitakan telah pun diberikan tarikh iaitu Jumaat ini jam 10 pagi. Exco yang sepuluh orang pula dah tarik balik tindakan mahkamah dan kena bayar kos mahkamah. Maka kita pun ready for a new chapter lah — the stage is set untuk menghadap Yang Dipertuan Besar yang cuba diturunkan tak lama dahulu. OK, kita sudi memaafkan.

Tiba-tiba timbul adegan yang skripnya tak habis ditulis. Umno membuat pengumuman bahawa Ismail sudah resign. Dalam naratif ini, a new slate will be made untuk reset hubungan antara ahli politik dan raja berpelembagaan dengan peletakan jawatan si menteri besar. Sedap juga bunyi skrip ini. Ismail dan 10 orang ahli exco dah buat macam-macam yang mengundang murka Yang Dipertuan Besar — yang kalau saya pun susah nak maafkan. Jadi baguslah Umno mahu buang yang keruh dan ambil yang jernih.

Tetapi skrip adegan baharu ini belum lengkap. Istana kata surat yang dihantar oleh seorang individu itu datang selepas pengumuman Umno. Menurut Istana, si empunya subjek dalam surat itu tak datang pun maka perkenan tidak dapat diberikan. Tentulah terkejut apabila Istana mahu semak ketulenan surat yang dikirim.

Pada ketika itu, Ismail pun tak tahu skrip apa perlu dibaca. Anaknya bersuara dan berkata dia tak meyakini surat perletakkan jawatan itu. Dengar khabar Zahid semacam menegur anak Ismail dan berkata ini soal pentadbiran dan bukannya soal bapanya. Saya rasa teguran Zahid itu betul tetapi kita pun keliru tentang surat itu.

Ketika kita dijamukan dengan adegan-adegan bercelaru ini, tiba-tiba peristiwa lain mencelah. Tuanku Muhriz memanggil Ismail menghadap ahead of schedule dan pertemuan itu berlangsung selama satu jam setengah. Kita ingatkan Ismail yang masuk sebagai menteri besar akan keluar sebagai Adun biasa seperti yang diumumkan Umno, sebaliknya Ismail melangkah keluar masih sebagai menteri besar!

Baiklah, kita ingat dengan titah baginda itu semua adegan dalam drama ini akan settle.

Tetapi, Zahid berkeras bahawa satu nama sahaja dipanjangkan kepada Tuanku Muhriz untuk diperkenankan sebagai menteri besar baharu, walaupun Ismail masih menjalankan tugas seperti yang dititahkan baginda.

Sepanjang hidup saya, saya ingatkan pemenjaraan dan mata lebam Anwar Ibrahim adalah the greatest unforgettable saga tetapi I must admit drama ini pun hebat juga. Apa yang pada awalnya dilihat sebagai pertembungan antara Umno dan Istana kini menjadi pergelutan antara orang Umno.

Kalau semua sepuluh ahli exco dilantik maka sepatutnya kemelut di Negeri Sembilan akan berakhir. Lantas, kenapa agaknya Zahid adamant untuk menggantikan Ismail, yang kini sudah mendapat perkenan Istana?

Kalau pimpinan tertinggi Umno nak buat skrip lain pun biarlah untuk drama lain di suatu hari nanti, mungkin selepas setahun atau dua tahun. Beri ruang kepada rakyat Negeri Sembilan bernafas, selepas tercungap-cungap kita menonton opera Melayu yang bercabang-cabang jalan ceritanya.

Saya doakan selamat untuk semua ahli politik terlibat dan mengharapkan suatu happy ending — they all serve the rakyat with great service ever after. - FMT

Artikel ini adalah pandangan penulis dan tidak semestinya mewakili MMKtT

Negeri Sembilan crisis: from chaos to utter havoc

 What initially appeared to be a confrontation between Umno and the palace has turned into an internal power struggle within Umno.

tajuddin

What began as a political impasse over the absence of a state executive council and the inability to convene the state assembly has descended into further chaos, with a new candidate for menteri besar proposed to the Yang Dipertuan Besar while the incumbent remains in office.

It is understood that during their meeting two days ago, Tuanku Muhriz Tuanku Munawir allowed Ismail Lasim to continue serving as menteri besar. So why is Umno proposing another candidate for the ruler’s consideration? Could Negeri Sembilan end up with two menteris besar?

So, what happens next in Negeri Sembilan?

Ismail and Umno president Ahmad Zahid Hamidi have both expressed their desire to resolve this crisis, regardless of who instigated it, so that the state government can administer sans the unnecessary drama.

Now, I fully support what appears to be the sincerity of these two Malay leaders.

As I understand it, Ismail took the first step towards breaking the deadlock by withdrawing a letter seeking to remove Tuanku Muhriz as the state’s ruler.

Ismail requested an audience with the ruler – said to be granted for Friday morning – while the 10 state executive councillors withdrew their court action and were ordered to pay legal costs.

The epilogue to this convoluted saga was fast approaching, and the public was prepared to move on to a new chapter.

But, alas, came an unexpected twist in this drama.

Umno announced that Ismail had resigned.

I initially assumed the resignation intended to reset relations between the politicians and the constitutional ruler, starting with the menteri besar’s departure.

It sounded like a reasonable move. After all, Ismail and the 10 executive councillors had done plenty to incur the ruler’s displeasure, which even I found unforgivable.

So it seemed encouraging that Umno wanted to put the past behind it and start afresh.

However, the Negeri Sembilan palace has yet to verify the Juasseh assemblyman’s resignation as menteri besar. The comptroller of the Negeri Sembilan royal household said the supposed letter was sent only by an individual named Hamidi, who claimed to be from a law firm.

Under the state’s constitution, the menteri besar must submit his resignation to the Yang Dipertuan Besar of Negeri Sembilan, and it only takes effect with the ruler’s consent.

The palace’s desire to verify the letter’s authenticity certainly raises questions about it. At that point, Ismail seemed unsure which script he was supposed to follow.

Ismail’s son spoke out, questioning the authenticity of the resignation letter and earning a rebuke from Zahid, who asked why family members were wading into the matter when it was an administrative issue.

Zahid has a point, but the letter itself remains perplexing.

And just as the public was trying to make sense of these conflicting scenarios, another unexpected development unfolded.

Tuanku Muhriz summoned Ismail for an audience ahead of schedule. Their meeting lasted an hour and a half.

We thought Ismail, who entered the palace as menteri besar, would emerge as an ordinary assemblyman, as Umno had announced. Instead, he walked out of the palace still holding the post of menteri besar!

So much for the audience with the ruler being the finale to this drama.

But Zahid remains adamant that only one name was submitted to Tuanku Muhriz for approval as the new menteri besar, even though Ismail is still carrying out his duties as instructed by the ruler.

For much of my life, I thought Anwar Ibrahim’s imprisonment and black eye were part of the most unforgettable political saga I had ever witnessed. But I must admit, this drama is quite something, too.

What initially appeared to be a confrontation between Umno and the palace has turned into a power struggle within Umno itself.

Why is Zahid determined to replace Ismail, who now has the palace’s consent to remain in office?

If Umno’s top leadership wants to write another script, perhaps it should put it on hold for a year or two. Give the people of Negeri Sembilan some breathing space. This soap opera with its endless twists and turns has left us winded – though for the people’s sake, I hope this saga finds some closure. - FMT

The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of MMKtT

To shoot or not: rethinking police use of lethal force in a civil society

 Protecting police officers and protecting the public are not competing goals but complementary responsibilities of a professional law enforcement service.

From P Sundramoorthy

The Kuala Lumpur police chief’s recent directive for policemen to fire when they encounter threats, including situations where they have doubts or feel threatened, raises an important question about the use of firearms by law enforcement in a civil democratic society.

The statement followed a serious incident in Gombak where a police officer suffered severe injuries in a machete attack.

Understandably, the safety and security of policemen must never be compromised. Officers who put their lives at risk to protect society deserve institutional support, protection and the authority to respond effectively to dangerous situations.

However, the broader question is whether a shoot-first approach is consistent with the principles of democratic policing.

Criminologically, policemen operate in unpredictable and potentially dangerous environments. They are expected to protect the public, prevent crime and enforce the law, sometimes while making split-second decisions. Their right to self-defence must be recognised and the government must provide the appropriate training, equipment and support.

Nevertheless, the authority to use firearms carries exceptional responsibility. In democratic societies, the determining factor should not simply be whether an officer feels threatened, but whether the threat is sufficiently immediate and serious to justify lethal force.

Differences in threats

There is an important distinction between a perceived threat, an actual threat and an imminent threat to life.

An officer’s subjective apprehension cannot, by itself, automatically justify discharging a firearm. The nature of the threat, the individual’s conduct, available alternatives and immediate danger to others must be objectively assessed.

International standards, particularly the United Nations Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials, emphasise necessity, proportionality and restraint.

Firearms should be used only in exceptional circumstances, particularly where there is an imminent threat of death or serious injury and less extreme measures are insufficient. The preservation of human life must remain paramount.

A policy that encourages officers to shoot whenever they experience uncertainty or apprehension could have unintended consequences. It may increase unnecessary fatalities, undermine public confidence and expose officers and the police institution to legal or disciplinary scrutiny.

Excessive or disproportionate force can weaken police legitimacy, public cooperation and effective crime prevention.

Equipping our police force

This does not mean expecting officers to hesitate when confronted with an immediate and potentially fatal attack. They must instead be equipped to make lawful and proportionate decisions under pressure.

Police services in established democratic societies generally emphasise structured use-of-force frameworks that incorporate de-escalation, conflict management, communication and alternatives to lethal force wherever practicable.

For Malaysia, this discussion should encourage greater transparency concerning police standing orders, firearms policies and procedures governing the discharge of weapons.

Public confidence requires firearm incidents to be documented and investigated without fear or favour, with independent scrutiny where death or serious injury occurs.

Accountability, however, must not become a mechanism for discouraging officers from taking necessary action when their lives or the lives of innocent members of the public are in immediate danger.

Police officers and other law enforcement personnel have a legitimate right and responsibility to protect themselves and the public.

When confronted with an imminent and serious threat, particularly an armed attack capable of causing death or grievous injury, they must have the authority and confidence to act decisively, including using lethal force where it is legally justified and necessary.

They should not be expected to expose themselves or innocent people to avoidable danger because of uncertainty about their authority to defend life.

Continuous training in firearms and the use of lethal force is essential. It must not be treated as a one-off exercise during basic training but be ongoing, regularly assessed and updated to reflect changing criminal threats, operational realities, technological developments and international best practices.

The SOPs governing firearms and lethal force must also be reviewed periodically and updated whenever necessary. They should clearly explain the circumstances in which firearms may be used, officers’ responsibilities, reporting requirements and post-incident procedures.

Ambiguous instructions place officers and the public at risk; clear, practical guidance is indispensable.

Ultimately, protecting police officers and protecting the public are not competing objectives. They are complementary responsibilities of a professional law enforcement service. Officers must not be expected to sacrifice their lives unnecessarily, nor should the public face an unrestricted use of lethal force.

The question is therefore not simply whether police should shoot or not. It is whether the circumstances legally, reasonably and objectively justify lethal force.

In a civil democratic society, officers must be decisive when confronting genuine and imminent threats to life, while restraint, professionalism, continuous training and accountability remain integral to the exercise of their authority.

The legitimacy of policing depends not merely on the ability to use force but on knowing when its use is justified and when it is not. - FMT

P Sundramoorthy is a criminologist at the Centre for Policy Research at Universiti Sains Malaysia.

The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of MMKtT