The appeals bench says the liquidator must be allowed to realise assets and investigate the alleged transfer of RM11.66 million.

Court of Appeal judge Zaini Mazlan, who chaired a three-member panel, said the applicant had failed to demonstrate special circumstances warranting a stay of the winding-up order dated Sept 30.
The panel also comprised Justices Leonard David Shim and Latifah Tahar.
Chin had sought to restrain the liquidator from realising Genneva’s assets, particularly about 28.3kg of gold, and distributing the proceeds to creditors pending the disposal of his appeal against the winding-up order.
He argued that any sale or distribution would be difficult to reverse if the appeal ultimately succeeded, potentially rendering the appeal nugatory.
However, the court rejected the argument, holding that the realisation of assets and distribution of proceeds were ordinary functions of a liquidator in winding-up proceedings.
“The fact that these steps may take place before the appeal is disposed of does not, in our opinion, constitute special circumstances,” said Zaini.
The court noted that Genneva had ceased operations in 2009 and had remained dormant since, with no ongoing business or commercial activities that would be disrupted by the continuation of the winding-up order.
The panel also observed that the applicant had maintained that Genneva’s assets exceeded its liabilities and that the winding-up order was not made based on insolvency.
In addition, the court took into consideration the liquidator’s ongoing investigation into the alleged transfer of approximately RM11.66 million from Genneva’s bank accounts to the client account of Messrs Gooi & Azura, saying the liquidator must be allowed to discharge his statutory duties.
“The balance of justice does not favour granting the stay,” Zaini said.
The application was dismissed unanimously, with costs of RM15,000 each awarded to the first and second respondents. No costs were awarded to the interveners.
Matthew Thomas Philip and Kimberly Teh appeared for Chin while Alvin Tang, S Muhillan, Lucy Lee, Kang Zhen Leong and Samantha Sum represented the petitioner.
S Ravenesan and S Naveennesan acted for the liquidator, while Afdhilani Jusoh appeared for the interveners-cum-creditors. - FMT



No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.