Karim Ibrahim’s exit ends a troubled presidency, but the executive council that helped pave the way for his return must now answer for its own failures.

Karim Ibrahim’s departure from Malaysia Athletics (MA) should have happened years ago. That it took intervention from World Athletics and a constitutional overhaul to end his presidency says plenty about the federation’s failure to put its own house in order.
The lifetime ban imposed on Karim in 2018 was never lifted. The Court of Arbitration for Sport upheld the findings against him. Yet he returned as MA president in June 2025, relying on a domestic constitutional provision that limited disqualification to five years.World Athletics continued to regard him as permanently ineligible. MA’s rules, meanwhile, gave him a route back.
That contradiction should never have been allowed to stand.
A national federation cannot claim to represent its sport internationally while maintaining eligibility rules that conflict with those of its international governing body.
World Athletics’ intervention in January this year exposed a failure that MA should have recognised and addressed long before it was forced to do so.
But Karim was not the only person responsible for this episode.
Where were the watchdogs?
MA’s executive council, made up of representatives from its state affiliates, cannot escape scrutiny.
The five-year disqualification provision did not simply find its way into the constitution. It went through the executive council before being put to the affiliates and approved at the AGM.
The very people entrusted with overseeing the federation were part of the process that created the provision allowing Karim to return.
What questions were raised along the way? Did anyone challenge how a domestic five-year disqualification could coexist with a lifetime ban imposed by World Athletics? Did the council consider the consequences for Malaysia’s standing in international athletics?
These are not minor oversights. They go to the heart of what an executive council is supposed to do.
Its members are not there to fill seats, attend meetings or wait for the next overseas competition. They are there to govern, scrutinise decisions and hold the administration accountable.
That means challenging proposals when they threaten the federation’s credibility.
The affiliates cannot now treat the affair as somebody else’s mistake. Their representatives were part of the process, and the provision was approved at their AGM.
An executive council that fails to question decisions of this magnitude is not doing its job. MA needs fewer passengers and more watchdogs – people prepared to challenge the leadership, even when the questions are uncomfortable.
A new rulebook is not enough
The amended constitution is a necessary correction. It is not, by itself, proof that MA has turned a corner.
The federation must now apply its eligibility rules consistently, conduct transparent elections and make its executive council answerable for the decisions it takes. It must also clarify how the new requirements affect its state affiliates.
Karim remains president of the Perak Athletics Association. His disqualification from holding office within MA raises an obvious question about whether he can continue in that state role. MA and Perak must clarify the position rather than leave it to assumption.
But governance is only part of the job. Malaysian athletics has a sporting purpose that has too often been overshadowed by its administrative troubles.
MA must develop athletes, support coaches, strengthen grassroots programmes and build a credible pathway to international competition.
These responsibilities cannot keep taking a back seat while office bearers argue over positions and control.
There is more to being an office bearer than travelling with delegations, attending functions and occupying a seat at meetings. The job is to serve the sport.
The 2027 SEA Games will offer another measure of the country’s ambitions, but the federation’s performance should not be judged by medals alone.
It should also be judged by the quality of the system that produces the athletes and supports those who work with them.
Karim’s exit should be a turning point, not a victory lap for those who remain.
The executive council must examine its own record: the provision it helped put through, the questions it asked or failed to ask, and the consequences that followed.
State affiliates must decide whether their representatives are there to protect the sport or simply occupy positions within its administration.
Karim is gone from the MA presidency. The people who helped create the conditions for his return are still there.
It is time they stopped being passengers. - FMT
The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of MMKtT



No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.