MALAYSIA Tanah Tumpah Darahku


Thursday, April 30, 2020

The case of the two 'MCO fishermen' ends well


It was a Thursday. The second day of April. The two men got off their Honda cub motorcycle, by the pond. They began fishing with their fishing rods. They hoped their catch would feed their families.
Poh Wah, 56 years and Chee Wei, 45 years, are daily wage earners. They do house repairs. They had no work and no income for 14 days since March 18 when the Covid-19 movement control order came into effect.
Policemen spotted the duo fishing. The High Court judge who heard their case on appeal wrote that they “gracefully tendered their friendly advice to the duo” to stop fishing and go home. The duo refused.
The judge added,, “If they had heeded to the advice and moved away from the fishing pond to home, they would not have succumbed to the arms of the law.”
The duo was arrested. They were charged in the Sungei Siput Magistrates Court the next day. They pleaded guilty. They were sentenced to three months imprisonment. They began serving their time.
There was a public outcry, for these were “fishermen” – as reported in headlines. The general public didn’t know the details about the “advice” given to them by the police and their refusal to comply.
The public only knew that they were too poor to pay any fine which might be imposed and so were compelled to accept a prison term. The public felt the punishment was excessive.
The case of the duo became the flag-bearer for the movement for a proportional punishment. A retired judge of the Court of Appeal spoke to the media two days after they were sentenced. He reminded High Court judges that they could call for a review of cases by lower courts.
A judicial commissioner (in common parlance, a “probationary High Court judge”) in Taiping, decided to look into the case. He “called for the records of the Sungei Siput Magistrates court with regard to the matter.”
In parallel, the young National Legal Aid Foundation (Yayasan Bantuan Guaman Kebangsaan, YGBK) lawyer acting for the duo applied to the same High Court to revise the decision of the lower court.
On April 8, Judicial Commissioner Muniandy Kannyappan heard the case. He revised the sentence handed out to the duo. He released them from incarceration – they had already spent six days in prison.
On April 29 (yesterday), he released his written judgment – which I quoted from above. As a layman, I found the following three paragraphs instructive with respect to speedy action by a judge, the need to punish defiance and choosing between sentencing options:
“[10] The pivotal issue is, is the sentence meted out proper in the circumstance of the case? The sentence passed may border on harshness or in the language of the CPC, of excessive severity, (see section 307(1) CPC) which plainly befits an appellate intervention. But the rigours of an appeal could be time demanding as there is a process which has to be adhered to, by which time the sentence meted may turn academic as the accused persons would have completed serving the sentence of imprisonment passed. ...”
“[12] The aim of the regulations is to promote public good as the rakyat is prostrating before the state and its machinery to alleviate the looming pandemic of Covid-19. Thus the conduct of its people has to be befitting and not to act in defiance to the state who is responsibly enforcing MCO via its law enforcement mechanism.”
“[30] In the premise, it would be appropriate for subordinate court judges to be mindful of all available sentencing options available in our penal system of justice, so as to afford an accused person justice in all sense of its attributes, as otherwise, it would be a right denied under the law.”
Paragraph 30 is music in my ears – especially since the judge put it in bold; it’s the only paragraph he put in bold. He said, in a judgment, what the attorney general should have said in statements or directives.
The judge sentenced the duo – who “committed violations which are not minor or trivial” – to public service at the Perak Compulsory Attendance Centre for “three months for four hours each day.”
The judge even said it is “unfathomable, for the accused persons as violators to remain in an overcrowded prison, where social distancing is near to an impossibility.”
I believe the magistrate erred tragically in this case, as dozens of magistrates have erred in thousands of MCO cases over the past 40 days.
I believe the attorney-general failed to intervene when he could have.
I also believe this judge has restored public confidence that some members of the judiciary are able to temper justice with mercy.
There is still much that is wrong with the sentencing of MCO violators. I hope the public will continue protesting, and that judges will continue to address issues with sentencing.
I hope the 11 new MCO detention centres will be un-utilized. I hope Poh Wah and Chee Wei have lots of work, catch lots of fish and obey the law.

RAMA RAMANATHAN is Citizen Action Group on Enforced Disappearance (CAGED) spokesperson. - Mkini

1 comment:

  1. I am really happy that i have been cured from (HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS) with the herbal medicine of Dr Aire , i have been suffering from this disease for the past 3 years and 4 mouth without solution until i came across the email of this doctor who have cure so many people with his herbal medicine, i also choose to give him a chance to help me and my husband, he told me what to do and i kindly did it, and he gave us his herbal medicine and direct me on how to use it, i also follow his instructions for use and he ask us to go for a check up after 1 week and 5days which i did, to my greatest surprise our result came out as negative, we are really happy that there is someone like this doctor who is ready to help anytime any day. To all the readers and viewers that is doubting this testimony stop doubting it and contact this doctor if you really have one and see if he will not actually help you. i am not a stupid woman that i will come out to the public and start saying what someone have not done for me and i know that there are some people out there who are really suffering and hurting their family just because of these diseases so you can to mail him on drairehome@gmail.com or WHATSAPP +2347036740271 he also told me that he has cure for these diseases listed below .
    Thank you for your time  


Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.