`


THERE IS NO GOD EXCEPT ALLAH
read:
MALAYSIA Tanah Tumpah Darahku

LOVE MALAYSIA!!!

 


 




Sunday, November 1, 2020

No need for emergency to avoid Borneo polls

 


Despite the recent decision by the Yang di-Pertuan Agong, the prime minister continues in his attempt to make a case for the need to declare an emergency as the only way to prevent the Batu Sapi by-election and the Sarawak state election from taking place. 

The argument being that holding a by-election or state election could result in a spike in Covid-19 infections and endanger the health and well-being of the rakyat. The prime minister, having learnt the lesson during the Sabah state elections, wishes to avoid a repeat of that incident.

In my view, this argument proceeds on a questionable premise, namely that the only solution to this problem is to stop the by-election and the Sarawak state election from taking place and to prevent the exercise of democratic processes in this country. I offer an alternative perspective and approach.

For the Batu Sapi by-election, which will take place on Dec 5, most political parties have already publicly declared that they will not contest the seat. And that they would give Warisan a walkover and let the Warisan candidate win uncontested. 

Given that the seat was held by the late Liew Vui Keong, who sadly left us on Oct 2 and who was from Warisan, allowing Warisan to retain the seat uncontested would result in there being no change in the number of parliamentary seats currently held by the various political parties in the Dewan Rakyat. In other words, it will preserve the status quo.

Interestingly, it is Perikatan Nasional itself, led by the prime minister, that has yet to state its intentions in respect of the Batu Sapi by-election. BN, Sabah Pakatan Harapan, PBS, PCS, and Star have all said that they would sit this by-election out. Will PN also put aside its political agenda for the sake of the nation?

In addition, if the electorate of Batu Sapi could persuade any potential independent candidates not to stand, and if the major political parties can ensure their members do not support and sponsor an independent candidate, there will be only one Warisan candidate on nomination day on Nov 23. 

If there is only one candidate on nomination day, he or she will win unopposed and there would be no need for a campaigning period or for an election. The constitution would be respected, the law would be followed, and no one’s health would be jeopardised.

As for the Sarawak state election, this has to be held no later than Aug 6, 2021. This is because the first sitting of the Sarawak state legislative assembly after the last state election was on June 7, 2016. The maximum life-span of the state legislative assembly is five years, at which point the assembly will be dissolved automatically.

Hybrid campaign

Unless called earlier, elections must then be held within 60 days of that dissolution. There are just over nine months to go between now and Aug 6, 2021.

The Sarawak state legislative assembly building

There is more than enough time for the Dewan Rakyat to pass such new laws as are necessary, or to amend existing ones, and for the Election Commission to make new regulations or amend existing ones, for a purely postal ballot election to take place. 

Nine months is ample time to educate the voters on how to register for, obtain, and vote with a postal ballot. Guidelines could be drafted to carry out an online-only election campaign or to utilise current guidelines to have a hybrid campaign, with a limited number of in-person attendees.

Expanding the eligibility of postal voting to all registered voters in Sarawak would in fact increase and strengthen democracy by enfranchising a greater number of the electorate. Sarawak could make history by being the first state to hold an election that is conducted purely and fully by postal voting.

One argument may be, why wait till the last minute to have the Sarawak state election? Actually, having it earlier would be an attempt by the Sarawak state government to find the most politically-opportune time to hold an election and to maximise the advantage and benefit to the incumbent government. Wouldn't that be considered politicking?

Which is precisely what the Yang di-Pertuan Agong has advised politicians to stop doing.

Adjustments to the way in which the Batu Sapi by-election and the Sarawak state election are to be carried out can be accomplished if only there is the political will to do so. There is, I repeat, no need whatsoever to keep insisting that declaring an emergency is the only way to delay the Batu Sapi by-election and Sarawak state election. 

All it requires is a genuine desire to find an acceptable solution that upholds the constitution and the rule of law, rather than an attempt to disregard these in the name of a so-called threat to national security, or economic life, or public health. 

If the prime minister and his cabinet would spend more time working with the
opposition to come up with a mutually-acceptable solution, rather than to continue harping about the need for an emergency, I have every confidence that the rakyat will be able to get through this in a responsible and mature manner. Will our political leaders do the needful?


ANDREW KHOO is an advocate and solicitor and co-chairs the Bar Council Constitutional Law Committee. He writes here in his personal capacity. - Mkini

The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of MMKtT.

YOURSAY | Dr M, never any justification for saying there’s a ‘right’ to kill

 


YOURSAY | ‘The Almighty does not need us feeble beings to defend His honour.’

COMMENT | Row with France - why is Mahathir so full of hate?

Vijay47: I shall refrain from going into Dr Mahathir Mohamad’s arguments in his proud justification of the gruesome killings in France.

It would be futile and foolhardy for me to do so considering the depth of the logic he has displayed, a level not encountered in even primary school dropouts. What is there to comment on if this is what a political leader, a former prime minister, a man in his 90s, can produce in defence of his religion?

To Malaysians, Mahathir’s statements are not new, though shocking only in degree. Foreign Minister Hishammuddin Hussein and now Mahathir, Umno’s top leaders, past or present, have clearly revealed not just to France but to the whole world what some Malaysian Muslim political leadership is capable of, the kind of extremism they harbour.

There would certainly be some who would support him, but does Mahathir really expect to earn widespread admiration for his insane views?

On the contrary, even at the local level, many Muslim leaders would shun him when he has gone so far out on a limb to voice crazy suggestions. Does anyone think that Umno leader Tengku Razaleigh Hamzah, Amanah leader Mohamad Sabu, or even PAS leader Abdul Hadi Awang would want to sit with Mahathir to discuss Muslim unity or even mundane issues?

For sure, there are Islamic extremists who take immense pleasure in slicing throats and raping children, but these are savage aberrations that the bulk of Muslims and humankind do not share. All that Mahathir has succeeded in is to reveal that he is a leprous pariah.

Revered Christian figures have been mocked and insulted, so have Hindu gods and less frequently, Buddhist elements. Do Christians, Hindus, Jews, or Buddhists take to slaughtering people for perceived insults?

Malaysiakini columnist Mariam Mokhtar asks why Mahathir is consumed by this unmitigated hatred. I would hazard that religious fervour cannot be the reason. Mahathir is a psychoanalyst’s delight, many of the demons torturing him being focused on the fact that for all his Malay bravado, he will always remain an Indian from Kerala.

For comfort, he can enjoy the company of Islamic preacher Zakir Naik.

Business First: The killing of innocents, regardless of religion, Christians, Hindus, Buddhists, Yazidis, and Muslims, is horrible, and at times like these, normal rational human beings give comfort and consolation to the victims. Like what happened in New Zealand. Christians stood in solidarity with Muslims.

In Malaysia, we have Mahathir who blames France's colonial past to suggest that killings of millions more could be justified, so in some perverse way is he saying that one should be grateful that this has not happened? It’s madness.

I am sure in many civilised countries with "hate speech" laws, this would qualify as "hate speech". However, considering the Malaysia of today, we know even if there are such laws, I doubt anything will happen. Because in Malaysia, we have "no double standards". "All are equal before the law", except that some are more equal than others.

I am not sure if Malaysians are aware that race and religious supremacists are mirroring Nazi German ideology in many ways. Its evil seed has taken root across generations.

Mahathir's comments and the silence of Malay Muslim leaders to condemn atrocities by Muslim extremists is troubling. It is not that they have no sense of morality; when the New Zealand mosque massacre occurred, we had the proverbial beating of breasts, etc.

For Malaysia to have credibility, we must without reservation condemn all acts of extremism caused by anyone regardless of who they are, and have compassion for all victims regardless of who they are, and not make excuses. I think most reasonable people would agree with this.

Malaysian Bulldog: Well said, Mariam. Whilst I do feel that freedom of expression must be coupled with a sense of social responsibility, Mahathir's remarks are so incredibly archaic in tone it is shocking. And ditto that of Turkey’s President Recep Tayyip Erdogan.

Erdogan attacks French President Emmanuel Macron's mental acuity instead of being more substantive and perhaps, talk to Macron about what is causing such horribly violent actions by certain individuals.

No, Erdogan and Mahathir come across as backward thinking, irrational people who instead of trying to help find peaceful solutions, display this siege mentality that promotes hate, divisiveness, and mistrust amongst Muslims towards non-Muslims.

Noor M: Dear Mariam, what is the crux of your argument here - what Mahathir said or himself?

It seems you wrote more on Mahathir than what he said. We had the worst attack on Muslims in mosques in New Zealand some time back. Did any Muslim leader condemn the Christian religion? All we did was condemn the person.

That’s what Macron should have done, condemn and curse the doer, the guy who was crazy to do such an act. Only those who are mad and insane will kill another, let it be on whatever reason that is.

So Mariam, I appreciate your view(s), and you are entitled to one, but don’t let hatred lead you, then there will be no difference between you, Mahathir, the killer and Macron.

No Fear Nor Favour: @Noor M, Mariam is rational. You only read between the lines. Just go through a second reading. After which, dissect the contents and then think rationally before forming an opinion of her views.

It’s unfair to conclude that she bears hatred when she only speaks the truth without fear nor favour. Mahathir is one desperate individual who is losing his popularity and judgement.

In desperation, he is making remarks unnecessarily without a second thought, which may result in uncalled repercussions to our country. It’s unbecoming of a statesman.

AT-SIXX: Over thousands of years, religious wars have killed many - mostly the innocent. There's no end to killing each other, and no point going back to history to feel aggrieved or justified.

Religions are good - the problem is men who abuse them and justify their actions in the name of the Almighty.

If you think about it, the Almighty does not need us feeble beings to defend His honour. Those who kill in the name of the Almighty are an embarrassment to Him. Leaders who do not promote peace are even more embarrassing.

The Truth Is Out There: I believe Mahathir’s statement was misinterpreted. We must read the following sentences after his quote which states:

"But by and large the Muslims have not applied the ‘eye for an eye’ law. Muslims don’t. The French shouldn’t. Instead, the French should teach their people to respect other people’s feelings."

Beman: @The Truth, what he wrote: “Muslims have a right to be angry and to kill millions of French people for the massacres of the past.”

The next few sentences that you quoted just said that those whom he deems to have the "right to kill French people" had not exercised that right yet.

So, in what way was he misinterpreted? He stated that a group of people have the right to kill millions of French people, just any French people.

Newday: Mariam, I always enjoy your writing - no holds barred. But I do have a concern regarding your comment that “Malays and Muslims eye non-Malays and non-Muslims with suspicion”.

We cannot be so generic with these labels. You are reinforcing the stereotype. Thirty percent of Malays who are Muslim voted for a better, more harmonious society in GE14. We didn’t quite get it but were closer than before.

Most of us have multi-racial and multi-religious relationships. We are Malaysian first and Malay second. We may not be the majority, but we are many. - Mkini

Lawyers: Emergency powers allow PM to suspend polls, but no reason they can’t proceed

 Prime Minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin delivers a speech during a meet-and-greet event at a restaurant in Pagoh October 30, 2020. — Bernama pic

Prime Minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin delivers a speech during a meet-and-greet event at a restaurant in Pagoh October 30, 2020. — Bernama pic

KUALA LUMPUR, Nov 1 — Lawyers have explained that the prime minister will indeed have powers to suspend elections should a state of emergency be declared, after Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin suggested the move yesterday.

Muhyiddin’s suggestionwas criticised as an attempt to stifle democracy, with lawyers polled by Malay Mail saying that they don’t see why elections cannot still proceed anyway.

Lawyer Nizam Bashir said that when a proclamation of emergency is declared under Article 150 of the Constitution, it will empower Parliament or the Yang di-Pertuan Agong to enact crisis laws which also included suspending an election.

“Such laws may infringe any provision of the Constitution — Article 150(6) — and the executive can take all administrative measures it deems to combat the emergency in question.

“The issuance of a proclamation of emergency consequently may allow by-elections to be staved off depending on what emerged from the legislation and/or administrative measures that arise.

“Otherwise the typical requirements of the Federal Constitution are to be adhered to,” Nizam told Malay Mail.

Advance Tertiary College senior law lecturer and academic director Daniel Abishegam also echoed Nizam’s views that Article 150 allows the declaration of emergency ordinances that can supersede the Constitution, including suspending elections.

It is for this reason that Abishegam said any declaration of emergency must be done with great care, since it effectively gives the ruling government through the Agong almost absolute power.

Yesterday, Muhyiddin sought to convince the public of the need for an emergency even as his previous proposal to the Yang di-Pertuan Agong was rejected, saying that the upcoming Sarawak state election and the Batu Sapi by-election will still have to take place unless emergency is declared.

Citing the Federal Constitution, the prime minister said the elections will still have to proceed, noting the concern of Election Commission (EC) staff, who face a greater risk of exposure to Covid-19 while serving during the polls.

The Federal Constitution states that an election must be held within 60 days of the Batu Sapi seat being declared vacant by the EC, or the dissolution of the Sarawak State Legislative Assembly.

However, the Sarawak assembly is not set to be automatically dissolved until June next year, which would allow a state election to be held as far away as August next year.

This comes as Sarawak Chief Minister Datuk Patinggi Abang Johari Openg said earlier this month that he does not mind if the state holds its election later rather than sooner in light of the worsening Covid-19 situation in the country.

Meanwhile, the Batu Sapi by-election will be held on December 5, but most the parties have since opted against contesting it.

Muhyiddin’s Parti Pribumi Bersatu Malaysia is among those who have yet to announce its intention for the by-election.

Human rights lawyer Andrew Khoo also agreed on Article 150 and suspending elections, but stressed that the Sarawak state election will be far along enough for new laws to be passed so that an election can be safely held.

“There is still nine more months to go. There is enough time to pass new laws and make regulations and educate the voters to turn the Sarawak state election into a fully postal vote election," he said.

Based on this, Khoo said it is unnecessary for Muhyiddin to declare an emergency.

"If the prime minister can stop thinking about declaring an emergency and starts working now on practical alternative solutions, that would be a better solution,” he added.

International Islamic University of Malaysia’s associate professor Shamrahayu A. Aziz, however,  said that without an emergency, an election must be held.

“If there is an emergency, we can either have or not have elections. But if there is no emergency, we must have election within 60 days from the date the seat declared vacant or from the date the state legislative assembly is dissolved,” she told Malay Mail.

“If you don’t have an emergency, you must have an election. If you don’t want an election, you need to declare an emergency,” she added.

Historically, the Federation of Malaya held its first and second general elections in 1955 and 1959 while still under the Malayan Emergency which was proclaimed in June 1948 and only ended in July 1960.

Malaysia would be formed afterwards on 1963, and declared another emergency in 1969 following the bloody racial riots of May 13 after a general election that year. That emergency only ended in 1971 and Malaysia had its next general election on 1974.

Last week, Muhyiddin and his Cabinet attempted to request for the Agong to proclaim a state of emergency, a decision which was rejected by the Agong following a discourse with the Conference of Rulers.

Since the elections are inevitable, Muhyiddin said yesterday he has left it to the EC to determine the necessary SOPs, bearing in mind that voter turnout could be poor. - malaymail

Tamrin issues demand letter to Zuraida, Puad

 

Zuraida Kamaruddin and Puad Zarkashi have been issued letters of demand by Tamrin Ghafar.

PETALING JAYA: Businessman Tamrin Ghafar said he has sent a notice of demand to Housing and Local Government Minister Zuraida Kamaruddin and Umno Supreme Council member Puad Zarkashi for associating him with the direct tender of a project.

Tamrin, a former MP for Batu Berendam, said the same notice will be sent to bloggers and others who have defamed him including Aziz Yassin, a member of PPBM’s Supreme Council.

In a statement today, Tamrin said the letter to Zuraida was sent on Oct 13 and receipt was acknowledged on Oct 14 by her aide.

Tamrin did not give details of the contents of the notice. However, in defamation disputes, the plaintiff usually demands an apology and retraction of the defamatory statements, and damages.

Zuraida had previously said that Tamrin, as an adviser to Bumi Segar Indah Sdn Bhd, which was awarded the RM170.3 million contract for the solid waste project, had directly negotiated the deal with former finance minister Lim Guan Eng in November 2018.

Tamrin, in response, said the project was in fact negotiated by the Barisan Nasional government in 2017.

In August this year, the project was listed among 101 projects with a total value of RM6.61 billion said to have been granted through direct negotiations by the Pakatan Harapan government.

The list, released by the finance ministry, showed the housing and local government ministry as awarding a RM170.3 million contract to Bumi Segar Indah to build, operate and maintain a solid waste transfer station in Taman Beringin, Kepong.

Zuraida had said she had no knowledge of the project and later laid the blame on Lim, stating that he had agreed to reduce the project cost by 10% and advised Bumi Segar Indah to approach the housing and local government ministry to formally make a proposal for it. - FMT

No one is above the law – except politicians?

 

Nobody is above the law — without doubt, the most common line used by our politicians, police and other authorities when issuing a threat or warning to the public at large. It is a reminder to everyone that we are all born equal. But are we really?

While our politicians scramble for power to enjoy the spoils of war, the rest of the populace continue eking out a living for survival. If we are born equal, this would not be the case.

No one is above the law you say? Then tell me why is it that when Haziq Abdul Aziz went public with his supposed rendezvous with a minister no charges were filed against him? Surely he should have been charged for some offence or the other?

After all, when a man in Balik Pulau made a false report on Aug 23 to protect his 16-year-old son who rode a motorcycle without a licence, the man was charged under the Penal code.

When Plantation Industries and Commodities Minister Khairuddin Aman Razali returned from Turkey and failed to observe the self-quarantine rule, his case was stamped “no further action” or NFA by authorities looking into the case.

The authorities decided that this was because a health ministry personnel had apparently failed to hand the minister the quarantine order form or Form 14B to fill up.

But if the blame cannot be attributed to the minister, then shouldn’t the personnel from the health ministry be punished for the negligence and dereliction of duty for not ensuring that the minister was issued the said form?

Shouldn’t this health ministry official be made an example? I thought you said no one is above the law?

When the attorney-general dropped all corruption charges against ex-chief minister Musa Aman this year, there was a hue and cry from all quarters.

But when Dr Mahathir Mohamad became the 7th PM of the country, all corruption charges against Shafie Apdal of Warisan involving some RM1.5 billion were also dropped in August 2018, some three months after Pakatan Harapan came to power.

What’s the difference?

And while they were not clothed in “orange suits” (neither was former prime minister Najib Razak, Umno president Ahmad Zahid Hamidi and a few other VVIPs), others who were brought to court for what seems like minor charges in some cases were smartly dressed in the colour.

Then Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission deputy commissioner of operations Mohd Azam Baki said investigating officers have the discretion to decide whether arrested individuals should be made to wear the orange uniform.

But I was made to understand that nobody is above the law?

Until now no action has been taken against former federal tourism minister Mohamaddin Ketapi for saying the invasion in Lahad Datu by the Sulu in 2013 was a farce despite the fact that some police officers had lost their lives.

Mohamaddin, who is currently the MP for Silam and also Segama assemblyman, also infamously said during the Sabah election in September that the Covid-19 cases being reported daily was nothing more than a scare tactic of the Perikatan Nasional government.

In a video that went viral, he called on his supporters to stomp and kick anyone who faints in the polling lanes as he believed this fainting act was designed to scare away voters. But look at where Sabah is today with daily figures exceeding 500 Covid-19 cases or more!

Mohamaddin is being investigated under the Penal Code and the Communications and Multimedia Act.

But will he ever be charged? Or is he above the law?

Yet, there are daily reports of the masses being charged for flouting the conditional movement control order rules which include not wearing face masks, among other reasons, with summonses and fines running in the hundreds and thousands of ringgit.

Apparently because no one is above the law, or so we are told.

Perhaps this “no one is above the law” line should be confined to the annals of history, never to be used again by our politicians and the authorities for obvious reasons.

Instead, we should seriously consider using the now-famous words spoken by then prime minister Najib Razak in the Sibu by-election of May 2015 while campaigning for Barisan Nasional: “You help me, I help you.”

Clement Stanley is an FMT reader.

The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of MMKtT.

Marriage cleansing ceremony shows power of customary laws

 

A Murut bobolian carrying out the sogit ceremony involving the sacrifice of chickens, pigs and a buffalo.

KOTA KINABALU: A rarely-held ceremony in Sabah’s interior Keningau district is a reminder that age-old native customary laws and practices are still part of daily life among the state’s indigenous communities.

The sogit ceremony held recently at a village in Tulid, some 60km from Keningau town, was carried out by the Murut community. The term sogit among Sabah’s indigenous groups is loosely translated as compensation and atonement for going against the customs of the ethnic groups.

A sogit ceremony is necessary if a couple who are about to marry are found to be first cousins or closely related, such as an uncle and a niece, for example,” said Keningau indigenous community elder Amir Arif.

Amir said native customary laws are severe on any relationship deemed as incestous.

“There have been stories where in the olden days if siblings were found to be involved in an incestous relationship, they would be speared and their bodies would be left to float down the river.”

The bobolian watches as villagers assist the couple in submerging themselves in the river.

He said the sogit ceremony in Tulid in early October was held after a couple was found to be closely related to one another.

A video clip of that ceremony showed a bobolian or shaman striking the ground several times with a stick while chanting. Strung up on a pole nearby were two chickens and two pigs while a tied-up buffalo was laid on the ground.

After the bobolian finished chanting, the animals were slaughtered and drops of their blood were splattered onto the couple who were then ritually immersed in a nearby stream.

The Keningau native chief said the sogit ceremony was held to prevent any misfortune befalling the community, and served as a declaration that the family ties between the couple had been severed.

Sogit is usually imposed by the Native Courts in the respective districts, presided by chiefs such as Amir.

Penalties can be imposed on those found breaching the customary laws, such as trespassing on another person’s land, or hunting illegally, as well as issues such as calling off an engagement or even adultery. - FMT

Muhyiddin avoiding Umno over 'new deal'?

 


Some Umno leaders are accusing Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin of avoiding them to discuss new conditions for the party to continue cooperating with Perikatan Nasional.

This followed several attempts by Umno leaders to meet Muhyiddin after the Umno supreme council's decision on Oct 26 to continue supporting the PN government.

"The prime minister was supposed to meet a top Umno official on Wednesday or Thursday. It didn't happen. The prime minister was too busy.

"Yesterday, the prime minister couldn't make it again. He had to be in Pagoh, Johor.

"We think Muhyiddin is avoiding us over the discussions of the new conditions," said an Umno source who is familiar with the ongoing negotiations.

The Umno source said this when asked on the latest developments on the discussions between the party and the PN coalition which Muhyiddin leads.

The relationship between Umno and PN has been increasingly tense in recent months, more so after the Sabah elections which saw PN taking the chief ministership.

According to the source, Umno's continued working relationship with Bersatu and PN hinges upon the new conditions.

"Although the Umno supreme council has resolved that Umno MPs will continue to support the PN government, whether or not that support will continue will depend on the feedback from the prime minister on the conditions which Umno will raise eventually," said the source.

According to the source, the Umno supreme council had on Oct 29 established a new committee to fine-tune the new conditions.

"The committee has four persons led by deputy president Mohamad Hasan. Other members are secretary-general Ahmad Maslan, former Perak menteri besar Zambry Abdul Kadir and former finance minister (II) Johari Abdul Ghani," he said.

Several Bersatu leaders contacted by Malaysiakini have yet to respond to a request for comments at the time of writing.

Meanwhile, a top Umno official told Malaysiakini that Muhyiddin would have to meet Umno leaders eventually.

"(Avoiding us) does not arise because the prime minister has to meet Umno on parliamentary affairs," said the official, who requested anonymity due to the sensitivity of the matter.

Parliament reconvenes on Monday. Malaysiakini understands that Muhyiddin will be in Kuala Lumpur to speak to PN MPs but there does not appear to be any scheduled meeting with non-PN MPs as yet. - Mkini