Counsel for two missionary groups argues that the law governing land titles in Melaka and Penang sets no time limit for obtaining replacement titles.

Counsel Cyrus Das, representing the two organisations, said the judge had made a fundamental error by raising the issue of delay when it had not been raised by the respondents in their affidavits.
Das said the judge had placed considerable emphasis on the alleged 18-year delay despite the respondents not raising it as an issue.
The lawyer appeared before a three-member bench chaired by Justice Azizul Azmi Adnan, sitting with Justices Faizah Jamaludin and Aliza Sulaiman.
He said the National Land Code (Penang and Malacca Titles) Act, which came into force on Jan 1, 1966, did not prescribe a time limit for obtaining a replacement land title.
“The Limitation Act does not apply to the National Land Code governing the two states of Melaka and Penang, which were formerly part of the Straits Settlements,” he said.
He said the two missionary organisations – Mother Superior of the Daughters of Charity of the Canossian Institute (Malaya), also known as the Canossian Sisters, and the Agent of the Commission of the Estates of the Portuguese Missions in China and Singapore (Portuguese Mission) – sought legal redress in 2022 as there was no avenue for them to approach a board to obtain a replacement title.
Benjamin Dawson, who also appeared for the appellants, said the disputed Lot 6 was not state land under Section 4 of the Act.
He said the two organisations had been occupying the land and there was no competing claim to it.
Counsel Joy Wilson Appukuttan, who also represented the appellants, referred to the transfer of another piece of land, saying it was initially transferred to the second appellant before being transferred to the first appellant, with the respondents’ involvement.
Melaka legal adviser Khairul Azreem Mamat, representing the land authorities, said the main issue was whether the appellants could compel the director to perform his statutory duties when no director had been appointed.
He also argued that the appellants had failed to submit Form E, as required under the Act.
Senior federal counsel Anis Wahidah Mohamad said the appellants failed to present sufficient evidence to establish a case requiring the respondents to answer.
She also questioned the application, saying it was unclear which of the two organisations was seeking to be registered as the landowner.
The Court of Appeal reserved its decision.
The High Court had dismissed the application last year, ruling that the two appellants failed to prove their ownership claim.
The court said neither organisation had established a pre-existing legal or beneficial ownership interest in Lot 6 when the relevant law came into force.
It also noted that the state had issued titles to other Christian institutions, including Christ Church Malacca, Convent Infant Jesus School, and Infant Jesus Convent, but said each case had to be decided on its own facts and circumstances. - FMT



No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.