`


THERE IS NO GOD EXCEPT ALLAH
read:
MALAYSIA Tanah Tumpah Darahku

LOVE MALAYSIA!!!

 


 




Saturday, November 21, 2026

Overcapacity should not be an excuse for protectionism

 True progress comes from pulling oneself up, not attempting to drag a competitor down.

WESTPORTS

From Jonathan Edward

The narrative surrounding Chinese industrial overcapacity is being used as a convenient scapegoat for domestic economic stagnation.

The recent comment by Mazli Noor China’s overcapacity, a test of Malaysia’s resilience exemplifies this point by suggesting that Malaysia must erect trade barriers, tighten anti-dumping regimes, and mandate local content rules to shield domestic producers from Chinese imports misses the fundamental mechanics of global trade.

If Malaysia wishes to thrive, it must either compete on the same terms through aggressive state-backed industrial policy or pivot towards producing different, higher-value goods and services.

Attempting to insulate uncompetitive industries behind regulatory walls is not a strategy for resilience, but a guarantee for economic obsolescence.

‘Overcapacity’ is a politically loaded talking point

The very term “overcapacity” is a politically loaded construct designed to frame superior manufacturing efficiency as a market distortion.

In April 2024, former US treasury secretary Janet Yellen warned that Chinese industrial overcapacity threatened global markets and Western workers – a claim China rejected, crediting its export success to market forces, scale, and supply chain integration rather than unfair manipulation.

State support has undeniably played a major role in China’s industrial ascent, yet there is nothing stopping Malaysia from adopting similar measures if it genuinely wishes to dominate heavy industries like crude steel.

If replicating China’s state-capitalist model is neither fiscally practical nor politically desirable for Putrajaya, then market forces must be allowed to dictate the outcome.

The failure of domestic protectionism

Malaysia already knows the consequences of coddling legacy industries. For decades, protectionist policies and selective state support have benefitted a handful of well-connected conglomerates without translating into broader economic dynamism.

Instead, these sheltered entities have repeatedly devolved into sluggish, uncompetitive monopolies that pass higher costs onto Malaysian consumers and downstream businesses.

It is an uncontroversial local reality that shielding domestic firms from foreign competition removes the very pressure required to innovate. Calling for anti-dumping duties and stricter customs hurdles will merely entrench inefficiency while penalising every Malaysian household and manufacturer that relies on affordable inputs.

Moving up the manufacturing value chain

Trying to compete head-to-head with the world’s largest manufacturing powerhouse on basic commodities like crude steel or bulk plastics is economic suicide. Rather than lamenting low capacity utilisation in legacy blast furnaces, Malaysia must upskill and upgrade its industrial base.

Modern manufacturing technologies, such as precision computer numerical control (CNC) machining, industrial 3D printing, and advanced metallurgy, allow smaller, agile firms to produce specialised components and bespoke widgets made from exotic materials.

Instead of churning out raw base stock, Malaysian manufacturers should be supplying precision-engineered parts for global aerospace, medical devices, and specialised equipment for the regional oil and gas sector.

Unlocking agriculture, aquaculture, and services

Malaysia’s economic future does not depend on matching China factory for factory when vast domestic sectors remain chronically underutilised. Consider agriculture and aquaculture, both of which possess immense export potential. For years, prime agricultural land has been squandered on speculative property developments that sit unsold, or cleared under questionable pretexts for logging.

Meanwhile, our rivers suffer from heavy sedimentation caused by upstream deforestation, alongside rampant chemical pollution and garbage dumping. Properly managed, Malaysia’s waterways could anchor a lucrative freshwater aquaculture export industry.

Malaysians are an inventive and entrepreneurial people. We have even successfully bred sturgeon in tropical conditions to produce luxury caviar. Imagine what could be achieved if environmental stewardship and agricultural land reform were treated as national priorities.

Similarly, Malaysia holds substantial natural advantages in high-value services. With a multilingual workforce and established legal and financial frameworks, the nation is well-positioned to expand aggressively into regional tech support, fintech, cross-border legal services, and financial advisory. Competing in brainpower and service delivery bypasses the physical scale advantages of Chinese manufacturing entirely.

Geopolitical hypocrisy and trade realities

Singling out China for its industrial might also ignores the broader geopolitical reality facing Southeast Asia. The US has swung toward unpredictable unilateralism, weaponising tariffs and imposing sweeping restrictions on artificial intelligence chips and advanced technologies. Its actions in the Middle East have kicked off the energy crisis the whole world is reeling from.

At the same time, the European Union is grappling with severe deindustrialisation and has become an increasingly cumbersome trade partner, imposing stringent regulatory barriers that directly threaten Malaysia’s environmental sovereignty and palm oil exports.

Why, then, should Malaysia lecture China for being a cost-effective manufacturer and a vital trading partner when we do not publicly chastise the US for its tech blockades or the European Union for its protectionist green mandates? Criticising the one major power that still possesses the capacity to produce at scale and low cost while offering a massive consumer market for Malaysian exports defies basic economic logic.

Adaptability over obstruction

Complaining about how well-resourced the competition happens to be reflects a defeatist mindset. True progress comes from pulling oneself up, not attempting to drag a competitor down. If Malaysia wants to empower local industry, it should immediately deregulate sectors where bureaucratic red tape suffocates enterprise, slash corporate and manufacturing taxes, and provide agile firms with the land, energy, and capital needed to scale.

Trying to restrain China’s industrial output is an exercise in futility, and attempting to freeze market dynamics is like trying to stop time itself.

Global manufacturing is constantly in motion. When a dominant power shifts its focus towards new frontiers, nimble competitors step in to fill the vacated space. Malaysian manufacturers must embrace this reality, pivot away from lost battles in heavy commodities, and capture the specialised, high-value niches where they can genuinely win. - FMT

Jonathan Edward is a media practitioner and an FMT reader.

The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of MMKtT

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.