PKR rep lacks understanding of LGBTQ persons, say groups

Several groups advocating for rights to freedom of expression and rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer (LGBTQ) persons have raised concerns over allegedly discriminatory comments made by an elected representative.

Justice for Sisters researcher S Thilaga said on top of drafting policies and serving their constituents, an elected representative has a role to play in addressing discrimination against all people.

Referring to a series of recent Tweets by Kota Anggerik assemblyperson Najwan Halimi (above), Thilaga said the PKR politician appears to lack understanding on issues surrounding discrimination and exclusion of LGBTQ persons.

"Discrimination and exclusion be it based on ethnicity, religion, gender, sexual orientation all have the same impact - inequality, injustice, marginalisation and victimisation.

"His lack of understanding of discrimination is worrying and will not allow him to address inequalities, disparities and be an effective representative," Thilaga (below) told Malaysiakini when contacted.

Taking to Twitter, Najwan had responded to another tweet that argued how society is partly to be blamed for gay men being forced to lead a double life.

This follows the conviction of five men in Selangor last week for attempting gay sex against the order of nature.

"Suddenly it is the society who has to shoulder the blame?," said Najwan in a tweet on Monday which sparked a series of responses.

In one response, he said it was "crazy" for LGBTQ defenders to expect society to accept their way of life.

Najwan's critics had accused him of inciting hatred against LGBTQ persons while others argued that he has a right to express a valid opinion against an unacceptable act.

Najwan further defended his views that supported the sentence delivered by Selangor Syariah High Court, challenging critics to point out how he had incited hatred against the LGBTQ community.

Contacted for comments, Najwan acknowledged the mixed responses to his tweets, particularly from LGBTQ supporters.

Contrary to his earlier sentiments, Najwan in a Facebook post today said he accepted existence of the LGBTQ community in Malaysia and respect their rights as provided for by the Federal Constitution.

While expressing support to uphold principles of human rights, he added that not all of the views advocated, including pro-LGBTQ views, are in line with Malaysia's cultural norms

"However, as a lawmaker, I am always open for a discussion and engagement on social issues related to public interest, including on LGBTQ issues," he said.

Commenting further, Thilaga said Najwan's earlier remarks showed little understanding on needs of the LGBTQ community.

"What we are seeking firstly, is to co-exist peacefully and with dignity.

"And secondly, for the state, private sector and everyday people to understand the systemic impact of exclusionary and discriminatory attitudes towards LGBT people," she stressed.

Meanwhile, Centre for Independent Journalism (CIJ) said exercising the rights to freedom of expression also comes with the responsibility to create a climate in which human rights are genuinely protected and promoted.

"Thus, Najwan Halimi, as a democratically elected representative, has the political responsibility and accountability to the people in promoting inclusive and non-discriminatory speech.

"While he is entitled to his opinion, he must ensure that it does not undermine the rights of any particular group," CIJ executive director Wathshlah Naidu told Malaysiakini.

She said such opinions should not be expressed in a manner that could advocate hatred and place LGBTQ persons at risk of aggravated forms of discrimination or violence.

Growing anti-LGBTQ sentiments

Meanwhile, human rights group Article 19 described the recent conviction, which carries a six months jail sentence, six strokes of the cane and RM4,800 fine, as a tangible manifestation of growing anti-LGBTQ sentiments in Malaysia.

"Intolerance seems to be gaining traction in online spaces, courtrooms and other public forums.

"The Pakatan Harapan government should act to ensure that discrimination is never given official sanction and consider positive measures to foster tolerance, including facilitating interfaith dialogue and passing comprehensive anti-discrimination legislation," said Article 19’s Malaysia programme officer Nalini Elumalai (above).

"It’s worrying that public figures are contributing to the stream of criticism and hate being directed at LGBTQI people.

"Elected officials and prominent individuals should use their positions to bend public sentiment towards tolerance, not prejudice," she commented further on Najwan's earlier remarks.

Last week, a group consisting of 28 human rights NGOs and a political party condemned the court ruling as it noted an increase hostility and alarming trend of prosecution against LGBTQ persons in the country. - Mkini