This is an article by Azly Rahman. You can click on his name for the link to his Blog. I have some comments at the end.
by azly rahman
I am telling it like it is, as an educator who would like to see radical changes in the way we educate the curious young minds to excel to the fullest of their potentials and beyond. In a culturally, economically, and cognitively diverse country such as Malaysia, we ought to have put in place an education system that capitalises on the strength of our diversity rather that see the seeds of destruction grow into a forest of damnation and despair.
Many of the leaders in our society have spoken on the need for radical changes in our system.
Here are my thoughts for policymakers to take note and put into action:
We are endangering the minds of our children. Our education system is breeding mediocrity and an unthinking citizenry. Our curriculum is not challenging enough to meet the needs of globalisation and to create the next generation of children who will become global thinkers able to produce ideas and to translate them into artifacts and applications that would help advance the social, creative, critical, and ethical purpose of humankind.
There is a disjuncture between what we wish to showcase (e.g. the Multimedia Super Corridor or MSC and BioTech Nation) with what we are teaching children in school. We have created spaces of knowledge and power in the framework of education and national economic development.
We are only interested in producing a generation of students skilled in memorising facts and to regurgitate them when the need arises - we have little interest in giving birth to thinking citizens who are able to relate to each other inter-culturally, and able to be transformed into life-long learners, imbued with the passion of changing the nature of society and government when the ruling class no longer serves the interest of the rakyat/masses.
We have created many generations of followers and silenced the majority, happily living their lives as one-dimensional beings, blind and mute to the massive corruption unfolding before their very eyes destroying the fabric of our ethical culture.
We are leaving our children in the hands of those who are ill-prepared to develop them into the “everyday genius”. We are full of slogans on success - “world-class this and that”, “regional hub for education”, “smart schools”, “vision schools”, “independent schools”, etc.
We are interested in rhetoric, in pleasing political visitors to our schools, in preparing our students to get 20As and to create showcase schools so that foreign and local corporations can also showcase their “generosity” and commitment to our educational system, paving the way for gentler and newer way of “glokal-styled” colonisation.
We are interested in cutting ribbons and displaying huge mock cheques and forcing our school-teachers to work long and late hours on things other than teaching and preparing for classes - on things that would only please the headmaster and the local politicians who do not have any idea how children develop cognitively.
We have been systematically killing the creativity of our teachers by burdening their minds with mundane activities to be completed out of unreasonable fear of authority.
We have successfully created classes of society through our classification system of schools and through the class ideology we directly or indirectly teach in our classrooms. We have schools for the rich and schools for the poor.
Wasting good talents
Like chicken eggs, we assign “grades” to our schools. When our schools are failing, we try to create independent schools and profit from more private schools, leaving behind the children of the poor of all races to be recycled in the system of structural mental-ideological violence. We are wasting good talents. Instead of making the slogan “brain gain” a reality, we are making “brains go down the drain”.
We have also created Mat Rempits, Ah Longs and gangsters in the estates. We have neglected the development of their minds and created successful failures through the schools we build. We have appointed educational leaders who perhaps have not set foot in the classroom, let alone in those of the most impoverished areas of our country.
We have created the worst group of people in our society whose job and passion is to promote hatred of others; using religion as a launching pad, as if the dangerous rhetoric of race and ethnicity is not enough to call for violence between and amongst races. This is what we are seeing as a violent reproduction of our education system as well.
The above ills are what we are seeing in our education system - after more than 50 years.
What then must we do for our gifted children of all races! A mind is a terrible thing to waste.
There is still hope for our children. But we must act now before the next generation of mediocre citizens are reproduced.
I am telling it like it is, as an educator who would like to see radical changes in the way we educate the curious young minds to excel to the fullest of their potentials and beyond. In a culturally, economically, and cognitively diverse country such as Malaysia, we ought to have put in place an education system that capitalises on the strength of our diversity rather that see the seeds of destruction grow into a forest of damnation and despair.
Many of the leaders in our society have spoken on the need for radical changes in our system.
Here are my thoughts for policymakers to take note and put into action:
We are endangering the minds of our children. Our education system is breeding mediocrity and an unthinking citizenry. Our curriculum is not challenging enough to meet the needs of globalisation and to create the next generation of children who will become global thinkers able to produce ideas and to translate them into artifacts and applications that would help advance the social, creative, critical, and ethical purpose of humankind.
There is a disjuncture between what we wish to showcase (e.g. the Multimedia Super Corridor or MSC and BioTech Nation) with what we are teaching children in school. We have created spaces of knowledge and power in the framework of education and national economic development.
We are only interested in producing a generation of students skilled in memorising facts and to regurgitate them when the need arises - we have little interest in giving birth to thinking citizens who are able to relate to each other inter-culturally, and able to be transformed into life-long learners, imbued with the passion of changing the nature of society and government when the ruling class no longer serves the interest of the rakyat/masses.
We have created many generations of followers and silenced the majority, happily living their lives as one-dimensional beings, blind and mute to the massive corruption unfolding before their very eyes destroying the fabric of our ethical culture.
We are leaving our children in the hands of those who are ill-prepared to develop them into the “everyday genius”. We are full of slogans on success - “world-class this and that”, “regional hub for education”, “smart schools”, “vision schools”, “independent schools”, etc.
We are interested in rhetoric, in pleasing political visitors to our schools, in preparing our students to get 20As and to create showcase schools so that foreign and local corporations can also showcase their “generosity” and commitment to our educational system, paving the way for gentler and newer way of “glokal-styled” colonisation.
We are interested in cutting ribbons and displaying huge mock cheques and forcing our school-teachers to work long and late hours on things other than teaching and preparing for classes - on things that would only please the headmaster and the local politicians who do not have any idea how children develop cognitively.
We have been systematically killing the creativity of our teachers by burdening their minds with mundane activities to be completed out of unreasonable fear of authority.
We have successfully created classes of society through our classification system of schools and through the class ideology we directly or indirectly teach in our classrooms. We have schools for the rich and schools for the poor.
Wasting good talents
Like chicken eggs, we assign “grades” to our schools. When our schools are failing, we try to create independent schools and profit from more private schools, leaving behind the children of the poor of all races to be recycled in the system of structural mental-ideological violence. We are wasting good talents. Instead of making the slogan “brain gain” a reality, we are making “brains go down the drain”.
We have also created Mat Rempits, Ah Longs and gangsters in the estates. We have neglected the development of their minds and created successful failures through the schools we build. We have appointed educational leaders who perhaps have not set foot in the classroom, let alone in those of the most impoverished areas of our country.
We have created the worst group of people in our society whose job and passion is to promote hatred of others; using religion as a launching pad, as if the dangerous rhetoric of race and ethnicity is not enough to call for violence between and amongst races. This is what we are seeing as a violent reproduction of our education system as well.
The above ills are what we are seeing in our education system - after more than 50 years.
What then must we do for our gifted children of all races! A mind is a terrible thing to waste.
There is still hope for our children. But we must act now before the next generation of mediocre citizens are reproduced.
My comments : I will group together some of Azly Rahman's comments
- job & passion is to promote hatred of others; using religion
- killing the creativity of our teachers
- leaving our children in the hands of those who are ill-prepared to develop them into the “everyday genius”
- breeding mediocrity and an unthinking citizenry
- students to get 20As
I see a common thread for all the above. Religion. However remember in Malaysia everything is racial. These observations do not apply equally for all students and for all teachers of all races. The "hatred" is coming out from the Muslim side. This is a fact. It is Muslim teachers who say 'speaking English is kafir', 'wishing Merry Christmas' is kafir, Chinese New Year is kafir, mixing with non Muslims is kafir, playing games with non Muslims is kafir.
When my boys were in primary school they would say that on Children's Day the cikgu will feed cake to the Muslim kids but for the non Muslim kids she would put it on their desks. This was 20 years ago. How can Muslim teachers become creative when they cannot discuss Darwin. What kind of creativity can you get when Muslim teachers say girls should not play volleyball? Or boys and girls cannot act in plays and dramas? (Except tadika kids).
Muslim teachers are also involved in scams selling kismis ajaib to students. Or other fake products to "make kids smarter". They also conduct qiyamulail prayers. All these kill creativity. You become creative and score As through hard work, reading, thinking and debating. You must face all views. Not just the views of people who look like you, think like you, walk like you, talk like you and bau masam like you. That will totally kill creativity. And all this is religion based.
So if they are mediocre and unthinking how do the kids get 20As? Because the passing marks and the 'A' marks are very low. What are the passing marks for Additional Mathematics? Is it true it is just 14 marks? What is the grade to get an A? If we set the passing marks and the 'A' grade very low of course we are going to manufacture hundreds of thousands of students who will not know what are their real capabilities. This is very unfair for the kids.
- We have also created Mat Rempits, Ah Longs and gangsters in the estates. We have neglected the development of their minds and created successful failures through the schools we build.
- We have appointed educational leaders who perhaps have not set foot in the classroom, let alone in those of the most impoverished areas of our country
- profit from more private schools, leaving behind the children of the poor of all races to be recycled in the system of structural mental-ideological violence.
- We have schools for the rich and schools for the poor
- local politicians who do not have any idea how children develop cognitively.
How come the MRSM and the sekolah asrama penuh still teach in English? The well known residential schools and colleges teach in English. They even prepare students for international examinations in English. Why the double standards? You are simply saying 'English for smart kids' and 'Malay for dumb kids'.
My view is the BN is going to get kicked out in 2018. The country is falling apart.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.