PETALING JAYA: A minister could have flouted penal laws, including the Sedition Act, for crudely suggesting that the “monarch has to listen” to the Cabinet, a lawyer said.
SN Nair said that by uttering such a statement, housing and local government minister Zuraida Kamaruddin reflected her “dangerously myopic” understanding of the workings of the Federal Constitution and other federal laws.
“Her statement borders on sedition for fomenting contempt, hatred and disaffection towards the King,” he told FMT.
The ex-cop turned lawyer said Zuraida may have also committed an offence under Section 124B of the Penal Code for an ‘activity detrimental to parliamentary democracy’.
Nair said this in response to Zuraidah’s stand that the issuing of a statement by the King on a proposal to revoke six emergency ordinances (EO) was “not proper”.
Talking to the hosts of the talk show “Consider This” on Astro Awani last night, the Perikatan Nasional Wanita chief said: “It is a waste of time to argue on this, when we know it will end up (with) something that is up to the government and Cabinet to decide, and the monarch has to listen.
“If he needs clarification, we (will) clarify with him to his satisfaction. So, that should be the way.”
Zuraida said the King, who was bound to act on the advice of the Cabinet in most matters, could have engaged with them first to seek clarification before issuing the Palace statement.
Nair said although Malaysia practised the Westminster system of parliamentary democracy, in law, the monarch is not a mere rubber stamp.
“The King has and always will retain residual prerogative powers. (The Constitution) is a fluid and living document, not a dead letter,” he added.
Lawyer Muhammad Rafique Rashid Ali said during an emergency, executive power rests with the King, and he is not bound to follow the advice of the prime minister or the Cabinet.
“Clearly the King had decided that the EOs should be repealed by Parliament,” he said, alluding to the Ruler’s virtual meeting with law minister Takiyuddin Hassan and attorney-general Idrus Harun on July 24.
On July 29, the Palace issued a statement that Putrajaya had not obtained the King’s consent. Later the same day, the Prime Minister’s Office responded that all laws were followed.
Earlier today, Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin said as the emergency had already ended on Aug 1, the issue regarding the revocation of the EOs by the King no longer arose.
Muhyiddin in a statement said the EOs would be brought to the Dewan Rakyat in September for debate, in line with the King’s decree on the matter. - FMT
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.