COMMENT This past week has been notable for two events. Firstly the anniversary of May 13 came and went without much fuss. The mainstream media largely ignored the event and so did politicians and the general public.
There were a few exceptions to the absence of attention given to May 13. A press statement from over 20 civil society organisations pledged to defend peace, inclusion and freedom in Malaysia and urging all political parties and politicians to openly declare that they will govern and administer on behalf of all Malaysians, irrespective of ethnicity, belief, gender and any other social standing and group membership.
By and large it is a good development that the tragic anniversary day was trouble free and also threat-free. In the past, Umno politicians have played the racial riot card on this day; and their extremist supporters have threatened to run amok anytime they have felt that the ‘pendatang’ are unreasonable in their demands for equality in the country.
Can another May 13 happen again in Malaysia? I personally do not think so for the following reasons.
The elite Malays of today in the palaces, Putrajaya, business world and other sectors where they dominate have too much to lose. There is no way they will allow a Malay-instigated racial riot to take place - even a limited one - because the cost to their own economic and financial interests will be too heavy.
If it was just a few Malays who belong to the elite and they have a small share of the national wealth, then perhaps it may happen. But the Malay upper class and elite now number in their tens if not hundreds of thousands; and they probably own just as much of the country’s wealth as the non-Malay elite.
Secondly, we now have an educated and politically-savvy Malay middle and upper class. I am sure that many who have voted for the opposition are aware of the way in which Umno manipulated the political environment after the 1969 elections which was a major factor in triggering off the racial blood bath. I am confident that this group will resist any attempt to frighten and instigate the Malays into senseless violence.
Thirdly - this is where the statement of the civil society organisations mentioned above is relevant - we have a Malaysian public - educated as well as less educated - who will not allow their futures to be hijacked by racial extremists.
I know that many analysts have doubts on whether the silent majority in the country will be able to react rationally should racial violence break out again. As for me, I am confident that Malaysians of all races will respond sensibly, protect their friends and neighbors irrespective of their race and religion, and help preserve the peace.
Fourthly, the spread of new communications technology in the form of social media and on the spot recording and feedback makes the waves of killings that took place in different parts of KL during May 13, 1969 impossible to replicate. Eyewitness response to the first killings in any new racial violence will ensure that biased accounts will be immediately repudiated and official censorship of news quickly exposed.
Finally, as with MH370, the eyes of the world will be on Malaysia. Those who instigate racial violence will not get away with it in the way they were able, 45 years ago.
Antics of Umno member Ahmad Said
The other event which was featured prominently in the news was the aborted resignation of the former Trengganu menteri besar, Ahmad Said, from Umno. So much has been written about this political wayang that it is not necessary for me to add further to the comments of other analysts.
All I need to say is that if a similar situation was to take place in the private sector - let us say that the CEO of a listed company resigns and calls a press conference to announce his departure from the company - the company will never accept him back. I stress the word “never”.
To me, the whole episode says all that needs to be said about the lack of honour, integrity and dignity in the country’s most dominant political party. It is sad that this party is setting the standard for Malay political behaviour.
If readers think my opinion is too harsh, they should read the following comment from the blogger, Syed Ali Akhbar. His analysis (which comes with font and colour emphasis) on the aftermath of the resignation is reproduced below:
Terengganu cri$i$ i$ over
$orry folk$. The 'eth' key on my laptop i$ jammed. I have to u$e the $ in$tead.
Thi$ i$ from The $tar
KEMAMAN: The political cri$i$ in Terengganu i$ over. Former Mentri Be$ar Ahmad $aid i$ back in Umno along with the two BN a$$emblymen who left the party with him.
Confirming hi$ return to the fold at a pre$$ conference at hi$ private re$idence in Kijal ye$terday, Ahmad pledged hi$ full $upport for hi$ $ucce$$or as Mentri Be$ar, Datuk Ahmad Razif Abdul Rahman.
The Kijal a$$emblyman earlier expre$$ed $upport for Prime Mini$ter and Umno pre$ident Datuk $eri Najib Tun Razak at their meeting in Putrajaya after a “mi$understanding” had been cleared up.
Ahmad $aid the mi$understanding wa$ over the date of hi$ daughter’$ wedding.
Alamak $o that$ what it wa$ all about. Just a $illy old mi$under$standing over a $imple wedding. We went to the election$, voted for the party and $illy thing$ like that to put an effective gomen in place.
But we are all $uch idiotic, kampong simpleton$. We forgot to a$k Ahmad $aid about hi$ daughter'$ wedding. Oh well.
Anyway a little bird called ye$terday and $aid that Ahmad $aid wanted 18 million duck$ for the daughter'$ wedding khenduri. That wa$ obviou$ly a gro$$ mi$calculation. 18 million duck$ i$ way too many. Finally Ahmad $aid $ettled for a much $maller number. But $ome duck$ were delivered.
$o the Terengganu cri$i$ i$ over.
KOON YEW YIN, a retired chartered engineer, is a philanthropist.
There were a few exceptions to the absence of attention given to May 13. A press statement from over 20 civil society organisations pledged to defend peace, inclusion and freedom in Malaysia and urging all political parties and politicians to openly declare that they will govern and administer on behalf of all Malaysians, irrespective of ethnicity, belief, gender and any other social standing and group membership.
By and large it is a good development that the tragic anniversary day was trouble free and also threat-free. In the past, Umno politicians have played the racial riot card on this day; and their extremist supporters have threatened to run amok anytime they have felt that the ‘pendatang’ are unreasonable in their demands for equality in the country.
Can another May 13 happen again in Malaysia? I personally do not think so for the following reasons.
The elite Malays of today in the palaces, Putrajaya, business world and other sectors where they dominate have too much to lose. There is no way they will allow a Malay-instigated racial riot to take place - even a limited one - because the cost to their own economic and financial interests will be too heavy.
If it was just a few Malays who belong to the elite and they have a small share of the national wealth, then perhaps it may happen. But the Malay upper class and elite now number in their tens if not hundreds of thousands; and they probably own just as much of the country’s wealth as the non-Malay elite.
Secondly, we now have an educated and politically-savvy Malay middle and upper class. I am sure that many who have voted for the opposition are aware of the way in which Umno manipulated the political environment after the 1969 elections which was a major factor in triggering off the racial blood bath. I am confident that this group will resist any attempt to frighten and instigate the Malays into senseless violence.
Thirdly - this is where the statement of the civil society organisations mentioned above is relevant - we have a Malaysian public - educated as well as less educated - who will not allow their futures to be hijacked by racial extremists.
I know that many analysts have doubts on whether the silent majority in the country will be able to react rationally should racial violence break out again. As for me, I am confident that Malaysians of all races will respond sensibly, protect their friends and neighbors irrespective of their race and religion, and help preserve the peace.
Fourthly, the spread of new communications technology in the form of social media and on the spot recording and feedback makes the waves of killings that took place in different parts of KL during May 13, 1969 impossible to replicate. Eyewitness response to the first killings in any new racial violence will ensure that biased accounts will be immediately repudiated and official censorship of news quickly exposed.
Finally, as with MH370, the eyes of the world will be on Malaysia. Those who instigate racial violence will not get away with it in the way they were able, 45 years ago.
Antics of Umno member Ahmad Said
The other event which was featured prominently in the news was the aborted resignation of the former Trengganu menteri besar, Ahmad Said, from Umno. So much has been written about this political wayang that it is not necessary for me to add further to the comments of other analysts.All I need to say is that if a similar situation was to take place in the private sector - let us say that the CEO of a listed company resigns and calls a press conference to announce his departure from the company - the company will never accept him back. I stress the word “never”.
To me, the whole episode says all that needs to be said about the lack of honour, integrity and dignity in the country’s most dominant political party. It is sad that this party is setting the standard for Malay political behaviour.
If readers think my opinion is too harsh, they should read the following comment from the blogger, Syed Ali Akhbar. His analysis (which comes with font and colour emphasis) on the aftermath of the resignation is reproduced below:
Terengganu cri$i$ i$ over
$orry folk$. The 'eth' key on my laptop i$ jammed. I have to u$e the $ in$tead.
Thi$ i$ from The $tar
KEMAMAN: The political cri$i$ in Terengganu i$ over. Former Mentri Be$ar Ahmad $aid i$ back in Umno along with the two BN a$$emblymen who left the party with him.
Confirming hi$ return to the fold at a pre$$ conference at hi$ private re$idence in Kijal ye$terday, Ahmad pledged hi$ full $upport for hi$ $ucce$$or as Mentri Be$ar, Datuk Ahmad Razif Abdul Rahman.
The Kijal a$$emblyman earlier expre$$ed $upport for Prime Mini$ter and Umno pre$ident Datuk $eri Najib Tun Razak at their meeting in Putrajaya after a “mi$understanding” had been cleared up.
Ahmad $aid the mi$understanding wa$ over the date of hi$ daughter’$ wedding.
Alamak $o that$ what it wa$ all about. Just a $illy old mi$under$standing over a $imple wedding. We went to the election$, voted for the party and $illy thing$ like that to put an effective gomen in place.
But we are all $uch idiotic, kampong simpleton$. We forgot to a$k Ahmad $aid about hi$ daughter'$ wedding. Oh well.
Anyway a little bird called ye$terday and $aid that Ahmad $aid wanted 18 million duck$ for the daughter'$ wedding khenduri. That wa$ obviou$ly a gro$$ mi$calculation. 18 million duck$ i$ way too many. Finally Ahmad $aid $ettled for a much $maller number. But $ome duck$ were delivered.
$o the Terengganu cri$i$ i$ over.
KOON YEW YIN, a retired chartered engineer, is a philanthropist.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.